Nykaa Black Magic Liquid Eye Liner – Dud ?

by Setu Shreya
4 minutes read

What is it? Nykaa Black Magic Liquid Eye Liner is a water-resistant and smudge-proof eyeliner. But is it really magical? Let us find out.

Nykaa Black Magic Liquid Eye Liner


Rs5 for 5ml

Sensitive Skin Alert?


How to use it?

Like the usual eye-liners, the brush dipped in the liquid is swayed on the eyes. As claimed, the brush does its work in one go.

My Experience With The Nykaa Black Magic Liquid Eye-Liner


The brush and its handle are way larger than the bottle. It helps to have a good grip on the brush and also helps to make different patterns easily.

Also, the bottle is quite travel-friendly.


It doesn’t have any fragrance. However, the color has a very unpleasant plastic-look appearance. It is also available in 7 different colors.


I had very excitedly ordered this NYKAA product but it turned down all the expectations I had from this very brand. The texture of the liner (as I told you earlier) looks like you have applied a black sticker (of plastic) on your eyes.

To make it look sober and normal, I had to apply my Kajal after applying the eye-liner.

  1. The packaging of the product
  2. The design of the brush
  3. Water-proof and smudge-proof

. . . And well, that’s it!


Well, there are many things in this section but the important ones are –

  1. The color texture of the eye-liner
  2. Not easily removable. Sometimes, its particles stick to eye-lashes and removing them becomes cumbersome.
  3. To give it a normalized look, one has to re-coat it with a Kajal.
Would I Repurchase Or Recommend?

A big NO. There are a plethora of good brands and eye-liners present out there and there is absolutely no gain in buying a product and regretting it every time you use it.

I would never repurchase the product. (Even if it’s the only eyeliner available in the market). And how can I Recommend something, I won’t buy myself.


More Liquid Eyeliners?
  1. Stay Quirky Liquid Eyeliner Blue BadAss 
  2. MAC Liquid Eyeliner Pen – Is it Worth Your Money ??
  3. Makeup Revolution London Liquid Waterproof Eyeliner: Uh Oh!
  4. Loreal Eyeliner: Loreal Liquid Liner Superliner is Not What You Thought!
  5. Maybelline Eyeliner Hypermatte Liquid Liner Review
  6. Oriflame Giordani Gold Liquid Eye Liner Review
  7. Mac Liquid Eyeliner Review
  8. Coloressence Super Extend Liquid Eyeliner Review
  9. E.L.F. Studio Precision Black Liquid Liner Review
  10. Coloressence Supreme Intense Liquid Liner Review
  11. Maybelline Hyperglossy Liquid Liner Black Review
  12. Street Wear Egyptian Blue Color Rich Liquid Eyeliner Review
  13. Maybelline Hyperglossy Liquid Liner Navy Blue Review

You may also like

Leave a Comment

1 comment

ashmita June 8, 2018 - 11:07 AM

i was about to buy it… thank you @setu :balleballe